Skip to content

Samuel Lipman

Released
Date of birth:1888
Gender:Male
Race:White
Era:1910s
State:New York
Time Imprisoned:
1 Year 10 Months 29 Days
Support
Anti-Militarism Anti-War Socialism Anarchism Socialist Party of America
Samuel Lipman

Biography

Samuel Lipman 21 at the time of his arrest; the lone Marxist socialist (rather than anarchist) among the Abrams defendants and a worker in the fur trade. Authored the English-language leaflet — the milder of the two leaflets at issue. Convicted Oct 23, 1918 under the Sedition Act; sentenced to 20 years and $1,000 fine. Deported to Soviet Russia Nov 24, 1921. There became a Communist Party member and economist; arrested in Stalin's Great Purge and reportedly executed in 1937.

From Kenyon Zimmer's Red Scare Deportees index (kenyonzimmer.com, compiled from INS deportation case files): Lipman belonged to the Socialist Party of America as well as New York’s anarchist Frayhayt Group, and identified as a leftwing socialist and Marxist rather than an anarchist. A pacifist and vegetarian strongly influenced by Leo Tolstoy, he lived with anarchist Ethel Bernstein, his common-law wife. In 1918 he was arrested with others for distributing leaflets opposing US intervention in the Russian Civil War and sentenced to twenty years under the Espionage Act. While imprisoned he became disillusioned with Tolstoy and falsely claimed anarchist beliefs in hopes of deportation. After losing the landmark Supreme Court free-speech case Abrams v. United States, he was deported November 23, 1921.

In Russia he married Bernstein, studied agronomy, and became chairman of the Department of Economic Geography at the University of the Toilers of the East. In 1928 he applied to join the Communist Party. During Stalin’s purges in the 1930s he was executed.

Case

U.S. Penitentiary Atlanta
Charges: Conspiracy to violate the Sedition Act of 1918 (amending the Espionage Act of 1917) — four counts.
Arrested: Aug 23, 1918
Sentenced: Oct 25, 1918
Incarcerated: Dec 26, 1919
Released: Nov 24, 1921
In exile since: Nov 24, 1921
Sentence: Sentenced October 25, 1918 to 20 years and a $1,000 fine, and released on appellate bail in late 1918. After the Supreme Court affirmed, he jumped bail with his co-defendants and attempted to leave for Mexico from New Orleans; recaptured in December 1919, he entered the Atlanta Federal Penitentiary on December 26 or 27, 1919 — December 26 is the best-supported single date and is the one recorded, marked probable. Transferred to Ellis Island in late October 1921, he was handed a conditional presidential pardon on about November 23, 1921 — requiring permanent departure, not vindicating the conviction — and sailed for Libau, Latvia aboard the Estonia on November 24, 1921, the confirmed last day in United States custody: about 699 days of continuous federal penal and immigration detention. Charges as recorded: Conspiracy to violate the Sedition Act of 1918 (amending the Espionage Act of 1917) — four counts, for printing and distributing two leaflets on August 22-23, 1918: one denouncing President Wilson and American intervention in Russia, the other calling munitions workers to a general strike against producing weapons that might be used against revolutionary Russia. Abrams v. United States, 250 U.S. 616 (1919), affirmed 7-2 on November 10, 1919. He was one of five defendants whose convictions the Supreme Court reviewed under the four-count indictment: Hyman Rosansky, who cooperated with the prosecution, received three years; Gabriel Prober was acquitted; Jacob Schwartz died after the arrests before the case was completed.
Judge: Hon. Henry DeLamar Clayton Jr.
Convicted: Yes
Institution State: Georgia
Security: Maximum